A true hidden gem nestled right in the heart of downtown Warren, Indiana, the Wagon Wheel Tavern offers an inviting, historic, and wonderfully nostalgic escape. This beloved neighborhood fixture is known for its exceptionally friendly staff, rich small-town atmosphere, and generous portions of pub culinary classics. With a cozy interior that brings back childhood memories for long-time patrons, it is a laid-back local hotspot where friends gather to play pool, enjoy live music during the warmer seasons, or simply unwind with a cold beverage.
Bar games (including a unique L-shaped right-angle pool table), Jukebox with online music options, Sports, Seasonal concerts
Atmosphere & Dining Options
Casual, Cozy, Historic, Ideal for solo dining or groups; Serving Brunch, Lunch, and Dinner
Amenities
Bar onsite, Restrooms, Catering services available
Parking
Free parking lot, Free street parking, On-site parking, Extra parking in the rear
Payments
Credit cards, Debit cards, NFC mobile payments
Why Visit? Key Highlights
Legendary Burgers: Celebrated by patrons for their incredible flavor and size, with the multi-topping Garbage Burger, the Battered Hamburger, and the half-pound Hub Burger receiving massive praise.
Warm Small-Town Hospitality: Frequent visitors regularly highlight the welcoming owner, excellent table service, and happy employees who provide speedy service with a smile.
Unique Entertainment: Features two pool tables, including a highly unique, right-angle L-shaped pool table that serves as a major conversation piece.
Famous Friday Potato Night: A massive local draw where giant Idaho baker potatoes are cut in half, smashed flat on the grill, and loaded with a wide selection of customizable toppings.
Fantastic Beverage Variety: Offers an expansive, great beer selection (including popular choices like AmberBauch) alongside expertly mixed cocktails and hard liquor.
Menu and Rotating Specials
Rotating Dinner Specials
Served select weekdays starting at 4:00 PM or 5:00 PM to 8:00 PM
Item Name
Item Name
Alfredo
Lasagna
Baked Steak
One Pound Chop
BBQ Ribs
Pork Chops
Chicken and Noodles
Prime Rib
Country Fried Steak
Ribeye
Delmonico
Salmon
Frog Legs
Smoked Chops
Haddock
Steak and Shrimp
Jumbo Shrimp
Two Columns of Item Names Split Evenly
Tavern Classics
Popular regular menu features
Item Name
Description
Hub Burger
A signature half-pound house burger
Garbage Burger
A fan-favorite burger loaded with a massive variety of toppings
Battered Hamburger
A unique, crispy burger reminiscent of a premium beef fritter
Breaded Tenderloin Sandwich
A classic midwestern golden-fried tenderloin
Cheeseburger
A traditional, perfectly melted cheese-topped pub burger
Pizza
Freshly baked tavern-style pizza with customizable toppings
Pizza Bites
Crispy, savory bite-sized pizza appetizers
Cheese Curds
Golden-fried, rich cheese curd bites
Jalapeno Poppers
Spicy, breaded jalapenos stuffed with cheese and fried crisp
Loaded French Fries
A generous portion of golden fries piled high with savory toppings
Breadsticks
Soft, freshly baked breadsticks served with dipping sauce
Baked Potatoes
Giant Idaho potatoes served with a selection of classic toppings
Fried Taters
Crispy, golden-fried potato side dish
Curly Fries
Seasoned, spiral-cut fried potatoes
Onion Rings
Thick-cut, golden-battered sweet onion rings
Fish Dinner
Crispy fried fish fillets served with fries and fresh coleslaw
