Nimrod Inn Bar & Supper Club offers a true “Up North” Wisconsin supper club experience in the heart of Athelstane. Nestled in Marinette County, this long-standing establishment is renowned for its laid-back atmosphere, friendly staff, and hearty classic meals. Whether you are stopping in for a cold drink after a day on the local trails or sitting down for a complete dinner with a fresh salad bar, Nimrod Inn Bar & Supper Club delivers warmth, generous portions, and traditional Midwestern flavors.
Wheelchair accessible entrance, parking lot, restroom, and seating
Atmosphere
Casual, cozy, historic, up-north charm
Amenities
Onsite bar, full salad bar, private dining room, restrooms, free Wi-Fi
Parking
Free onsite parking lot, free street parking
Payment Options
Credit cards, debit cards, NFC mobile payments
Why Visit? Key Highlights
Famous Salad Bar & Gizzards: A standout feature of the dining experience, the fresh salad bar includes soup, homemade bread, and their iconic sautéed chicken gizzards.
Signature Prime Rib & Steaks: Loved by locals and travelers alike, offering tender, expertly prepared cuts of prime rib on weekends alongside hand-cut steaks.
Friday Fish Fry Traditions: Featuring all-you-can-eat Alaskan walleye, broiled cod, perch, and deep-fried seafood options.
Classic Cocktails: Famous for hand-muddled Old Fashioneds (with traditional or unique mushroom garnishes) and legendary Bloody Marys.
Welcoming Environment: A warm, inviting stop suitable for families, large trail-riding groups, tourists, and outdoor enthusiasts.
Menu & Dining Offerings
Appetizers
Item Name
Description
French Fries
Crispy golden potatoes
Onion Rings
Thick-cut, battered fried onion rings
Chicken Strips
Golden-fried chicken tenderloins
Battered Mushrooms
Crispy breaded whole mushrooms
Battered White Cheddar Garlic Curds
Wisconsin cheese curds with garlic seasoning
Cream Cheese Poppers
Breaded jalapeños stuffed with cream cheese
Battered Mozzarella Sticks
Classic melted mozzarella in a crispy shell
Battered Cheese Cauliflower
Tender cauliflower florets in cheese batter
Broasted Wedges
Seasoned potato wedges
Mac & Cheese Bites
Jalapeño, classic mac, white cheddar, and bacon
Garlic Bread
Toasted garlic loaf (6 pieces)
Garlic Bread with Cheese
Melted cheese over garlic bread (6 pieces)
21 Breaded Shrimp
Bite-sized breaded shrimp
3 Battered Cod
Crispy battered cod pieces
Lunch Burgers & Sandwiches
Item Name
Description
Hamburger
Single or double stacked patty
Cheeseburger
Classic burger with melted cheese
Swiss Burger
Burger topped with Swiss cheese
Mushroom Swiss Burger
Sauteed mushrooms and Swiss cheese
Bacon Burger
Topped with crispy bacon strips
Bacon Cheeseburger
Bacon, cheese, and grilled beef patty
Bacon Cheeseburger OS
Onion stacked with lettuce, tomato, mayo, and onion rings
Deluxe Cheeseburger
Topped with lettuce, tomato, and mayo
Deluxe Cheeseburger OS
Onion stacked with lettuce, tomato, mayo, and onion rings
Grilled Chicken Fillet
Served with lettuce and mayo
Fish Sandwich
Tender fish fillet with lettuce and tartar sauce
BLT on Toast
Thick-cut bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayo
Prime Rib Philly Sandwich
Onion, green pepper, mushroom, mozzarella, and au jus
6 oz. Tenderloin Sandwich
Tender steak fillet on a warm roll
Nimrod Specialty Pizzas
Item Name
Description
Nimrod Inn Deluxe
Cheese, sausage, onion, mushrooms, green peppers, black olives, and pepperoni
Veggie
Tomatoes, onion, mushroom, green peppers, and black olives
Bacon Cheeseburger
Hamburger, pickles, bacon, and mustard
Meat Lover’s
Sausage, ham, pepperoni, and bacon
Chicken Bacon Ranch
Tender chicken, crispy bacon, and ranch sauce
Chicken and Broccoli Alfredo
Creamy alfredo base with chicken and broccoli
Cream Cheese, Jalapeño, Ham, & Pineapple
Sweet and spicy specialty combo
Steaks & Combination Dinners
Item Name
Description
Nimrod Special
10 oz. tenderloin topped with bacon and sauteed mushrooms
Tenderloin Cut
Available in 6 oz., 10 oz., or 16 oz. options
16-18 oz. Ribeye
Rich, marbled prime steak
16-18 oz. New York Strip
Center-cut flavorful strip steak
Tenderloin and Fantail Shrimp
6 oz. tenderloin paired with fantail shrimp
Tenderloin and Scampi
6 oz. tenderloin served with garlic and butter sauce scampi
Tenderloin and Chicken
6 oz. tenderloin paired with juicy chicken
Tenderloin and Lobster Tail
6 oz. tenderloin paired with lobster tail
Tenderloin and Half Rack Ribs
6 oz. tenderloin with tender baby back ribs
Tenderloin and Scallops
6 oz. tenderloin with sautéed or deep-fried scallops
Tenderloin and Stuffed Shrimp
6 oz. tenderloin with cheese-and-crabmeat stuffed shrimp
House Specialties, Pork, & Chicken
Item Name
Description
Baby Back Pork Ribs
Half rack or full rack of slow-cooked ribs
Prime Rib
King Cut (18-20 oz.), Queen Cut (14-16 oz.), or Petite Cut (10-12 oz.)
Broasted Pork Chops
One chop or two chop meal choices
Broasted Chicken
Quarter dark, quarter white, or half chicken options
