Crystal Creek Sandwich Co. is a relaxed, family-owned sandwich shop on S. Milton Road in Flagstaff, Arizona, known for dishing up toasted comfort fare, generous portions, vegetarian options, and a casual atmosphere complete with pool tables. Locals and visitors praise its fresh-baked bread, hearty made-to-order sandwiches, friendly counter service, and easygoing vibe that has made it a longtime Flagstaff favorite.
Detail Information Address 1051 S Milton Rd B, Flagstaff, AZ 86001, United States Phone +1 928-774-9373 Social Facebook Map Google Maps
Day Hours Monday 10 am – 5 pm Tuesday 10 am – 5 pm Wednesday 10 am – 5 pm Thursday 10 am – 5 pm Friday 10 am – 5 pm Saturday 10 am – 5 pm Sunday 10 am – 5 pm
Happy Hour is listed daily from 4–7 pm.
Category Details Service Options Dine-in, takeout, counter service Accessibility Wheelchair accessible entrance, parking lot, restroom, and seating Atmosphere Casual, cozy, local Flagstaff vibe Amenities Pool tables, restroom, 16 beers on tap Parking Free parking lot, free street parking (usually plentiful) Crowd & Suitability Good for kids, groups, college students, tourists, and solo dining Offerings Vegetarian options, comfort food, quick bites, healthy options, alcohol/beer Payments Credit cards, debit cards, NFC mobile payments
Consistently praised for oversized, fresh sandwiches packed with quality ingredients—many guests note a half portion is plenty
Fresh bread baked daily that regularly earns compliments for taste and texture
Friendly, fast, and accommodating service with staff happy to handle modifications
Standout favorite: the Grand Rapids sandwich, frequently called out as a must-try
Welcoming, low-key atmosphere with pool tables that works well for families, groups, or a casual solo lunch
Solid vegetarian options and the ability to customize
Convenient for both dine-in and quick takeout; popular lunch stop with a true local feel
Draft beer selection and happy hour specials add to the relaxed experience
Menu
Sandwiches served on a toasted white roll.
Item Description Bacon, Eggs and Avocado Melted cheddar cheese on your choice of bread Pastrami and Eggs Melted provolone cheese on your choice of bread Ham and Eggs Melted cheddar cheese on your choice of bread Sausage and Eggs Melted cheddar cheese on your choice of bread
Item Description Pastrami Provolone and spicy mustard on white bread French Dip Thinly sliced lean roast beef, provolone cheese, and au jus Spicy French Dip Thinly sliced lean roast beef, provolone cheese, cream cheese, mini green chilies, picante sauce, and au jus Pastrami Rueben Hot pastrami, cream cheese, Swiss, Thousand Island dressing, and sauerkraut on white bread Turkey Rueben Hot turkey, cream cheese, Swiss, Thousand Island dressing, and sauerkraut on white bread Italian Meatball Meatballs in marinara with provolone and Parmesan cheese on white bread Italian Sausage Mildly spicy sausage in marinara with provolone and Parmesan cheese on white bread Italian Combo Meatballs and sausage in marinara with provolone and Parmesan cheese on white bread Barbe-Q Beef, Ham or Turkey Choice of Swiss or provolone on white bread Turkey Beef Avocado Mayonnaise, tomatoes, cucumbers, Italian dressing, cheddar cheese, and lettuce on white bread Tuna Melt Albacore, mayonnaise, cheddar cheese, tomatoes, cucumbers, Italian dressing, and lettuce on white bread Spicy Italian Sandwich Salami, ham, onions, jalapenos, provolone, mayo, tomatoes, cucumbers, Italian dressing, and lettuce on white bread
These sandwiches include mayonnaise, tomatoes, cucumbers, Italian dressing, and lettuce.
Item Description Grand Rapids Genoa salami, smoked ham, turkey breast, lean roast beef, bacon, avocado, cream cheese, cheddar and provolone cheese on a white roll Crystal Rapids Genoa salami, smoked ham, turkey breast, lean roast beef, cheddar and provolone cheese on a white roll Crystal Club Turkey, ham, roast beef, bacon, avocado, and Swiss cheese Roast Beef Choice of cheddar or provolone cheese on a white roll
These sandwiches include mayonnaise, tomatoes, cucumbers, Italian dressing, and lettuce.
Item Description Turkey and Bacon Choice of cheddar or Swiss cheese on a wheat roll Turkey Avocado Choice of cheddar or Swiss cheese on a wheat roll Bacon Lettuce Tomato Avocado Cheddar cheese on a wheat roll Tuna Salad Tuna, avocado, and cheddar cheese on a wheat roll Chicken Salad Cheddar cheese (as listed on menu)
These sandwiches include mayonnaise, tomatoes, cucumbers, Italian dressing, and sprouts.
Item Description Crystal Veggie Avocados, cream cheese, walnuts, tomatoes, cucumbers, and cheddar cheese on a wheat roll Super Crystal Veggie Avocado, cream cheese, Swiss cheese, walnuts, and sprouts on a wheat roll Avocado Meadows Lots of avocado, cheddar cheese, Swiss cheese, artichoke hearts, and sprouts on a wheat roll Sonoran Veggie Cucumbers, green chilies, olives, picante sauce, cream cheese, avocado, and sprouts on a wheat roll
These sandwiches include mayonnaise, tomatoes, cucumbers, Italian dressing, and lettuce.
Item Description Turkey Breast Choice of cheddar or Swiss cheese on a wheat roll Smoked Ham Choice of Swiss or provolone cheese on a white roll Salami and Smoked Ham Swiss or provolone cheese on a white roll Turkey and Roast Beef Provolone cheese on a white roll Turkey and Salami Provolone cheese on a white roll
Item Description Garden Salad Tomatoes, cucumbers, olives, carrots, Italian dressing, and lettuce Salad with Tuna Tomatoes, cucumbers, olives, carrots, Italian dressing, and lettuce topped with Parmesan cheese Salad with Turkey Tomatoes, cucumbers, olives, carrots, Italian dressing, and lettuce topped with Parmesan cheese
Item Description Turkey Turkey and cheddar cheese Ham Ham and cheddar cheese Grilled Cheese Toasted on a white roll Peanut Butter and Jelly —
Item Description Potato or Macaroni Salad — Soup of the Day Cup or bowl
Side Orders & Extras
Item Description Chips — Cookies — Pepperoncini — Pickle (half or whole) — Bread (half or whole) — Extras and Additions Cheese, avocado, chilies, olives, artichokes, walnuts, au jus, picante, etc.
Item Description Fountain Drink — Lemonade or Strawberry Lemonade — Tea — Unsweetened or Raspberry — Bottled Drink — Chocolate Milk — Cold Coffee — Hot Tea and Hot Chocolate —
16 beers on tap. Happy hour daily 4–7 pm.
Category Options Domestics Budweiser, Bud Light, Coors Light, Miller Light, Pabst Blue Ribbon Premiums Kilt Lifter, OC Nut Brown, OC Amber Ale, Sierra Nevada Ale, Blue Moon, Historic IPA, New Belgium Fat Tire, Samuel Adams, Ranger IPA, Historic Porter
