Fratelli’s NY Pizza is a casual Italian eatery located in Thurmont, Maryland. Known for its extensive menu of New York-style comfort food and reliable local service, the restaurant has earned a 4.4-star rating from residents and visitors alike. Whether you are looking for an authentic thin-crust pizza or a hearty sub, Fratelli’s offers a “hidden gem” experience with massive portions at a value that is hard to find elsewhere.
Restaurant Overview
| Feature | Details |
| Location | 140 Frederick Rd, Thurmont, MD 21788 (Located in 7-Eleven) |
| Phone | +1 301-271-0272 |
| Website | fratellisnypizza.gbiz.shop |
| Operating Hours | Monday – Sunday: 11:00 AM – 8:00 PM |
| Service Options | Dine-in, Takeout, and Delivery |
| Social Media | Facebook | Google Maps |
Amenities and Accessibility
Fratelli’s provides a welcoming environment for all types of travelers, including families and professional drivers.
| Category | Available Features |
| Accessibility | Wheelchair-accessible parking and seating |
| Parking | Free onsite lot, free street parking, and dedicated truck parking in the back |
| Family Features | Kids’ menu, high chairs available, and a family-friendly atmosphere |
| Payments | Credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments (Apple/Google Pay) |
| Vibe | Casual, cozy, and no-frills “mom and pop” style |
Why Locals Love Fratelli’s
- Authentic Quality: Former New Yorkers praise the “yeasty chewy bite” and thin crust of the pizza.
- Massive Portions: Many meals are large enough to serve as two full portions.
- Exceptional Service: Owners are often on-site to greet customers, and the staff is known for going above and beyond, such as splitting plates for children or taking late orders.
- Great Value: Reviewers frequently mention that prices feel “like they are from 20 years ago”.
The Complete Menu
Fratelli’s offers a vast selection ranging from traditional Italian entrees to American deli favorites.
Pizza and Turn-Overs
| Category | Items |
| NY Style & Specialty | Cheese White Pie Hawaiian Meatball Fratelli’s Special Meat Lovers Chicken Ranch Veggie Veggie Bacon Ranch BBQ Chicken Buffalo Chicken Chicken Parm Cheeseburger Pizza Cheese Steak Pizza |
| Pizza Toppings | Pepperoni Mushrooms Sausage Ham Onions Salami Bacon Garlic Spinach Green Peppers Hamburger Capicolla Black Olives Banana Peppers Broccoli Fresh Tomatoes Pineapple |
| Sicilian | Thick Crust Pizza |
| Turn-Overs | Sausage or Pepperoni Rolls; Regular, Meatball, Veggie, or Steak Strombolis; Regular or Meatball Calzones |
Subs, Burgers, and Wraps
| Category | Items |
| Hot Subs | Steak & Cheese (Regular or Works) Bacon Steak & Cheese Pizza Steak Pizza Sub Pizza Burger Cheeseburger Chicken Cheese Steak Grilled Chicken Chicken Fillet Chicken or Veal Parmigiana Sausage & Cheese Meatball or Eggplant Parmigiana Veggie Sub Hot Turkey & Cheese, and Hot Ham & Cheese |
| Cold Subs & Clubs | Italian Super Italian Ham & Cheese Salami & Cheese Turkey Turkey & Cheese American Mixed Tuna, and Ham Capicolla & Cheese; Turkey, Ham, or Turkey & Ham Clubs |
| Burgers & Melts | Hamburger Cheeseburger Bacon Cheeseburger BBQ Cheeseburger, and BBQ Bacon Cheeseburger; Ham, Turkey, or Tuna Pretzel Melts |
| Wraps | Hamburger/Cheeseburger Cheese Steak Chicken (Buffalo, BBQ, Honey Mustard, or Bacon Ranch) Turkey, Ham, Veggie, Tuna, and Italian Wraps |
Entrees, Sides, and More
| Category | Items |
| Pasta Specialties | Lasagna Spaghetti (Tomato Sauce, Meat Sauce, Meatballs, or Sausage) Baked Ziti Stuffed Shells Manicotti Cheese Ravioli Fettuccine Alfredo, and Chicken or Veal Parmigiana with Spaghetti |
| Appetizers | Mozzarella Sticks Jalapeno Poppers Onion Rings Battered Mushrooms/Zucchini/Pickles Wings (Buffalo, BBQ, Old Bay, Spicy Honey) Bread Sticks Garlic Bows/Bread Fried Calamari, and Popcorn Chicken |
| Soups & Salads | Fratelli’s Tomato Chicken Noodle Pasta & Bean, and Clam Chowder; Side, Tossed, Greek, Tuna, Chicken, Garden, Antipasto, Chef, Mozzarella Caprese, and Steak Salads |
| Beverages | Pepsi products Sweet/Unsweet Tea Lemonade Root Beer, and Powerade |
| Desserts | Plain Cannoli Plain Cheesecake, and Peanut Butter Pie |
Daily and Lunch Specials
Fratelli’s offers a variety of deals to keep meals affordable throughout the week.
| Day | Special Offer |
| Monday | Crab Cake or Fish Sandwich with Fries; One Large Cheese Pizza |
| Tuesday | Cheeseburger with Fries; Two 16″ One-Topping Pizzas |
| Wednesday | Any Large Sub |
| Thursday | Pretzel Melt with Fries; Discounted 5 or 8 count Wings |
| Friday | Shrimp with Fries; Small Meatball Cheese Sub |
| Saturday | Discount off any Pasta Dinner; Two 16″ Cheese Pizzas |
| Sunday | Wrap with Fries; Discount off Pasta Dinners |
| Everyday (11-4) | Lunch Special: Small Sub with Fries |