Hartley’s Pizza is a cherished local landmark located in the heart of Cumberland, Maryland. Known for its relaxed atmosphere and commitment to quality, this neighborhood staple has earned a reputation for serving some of the freshest pizza, wings, and signature “wedgies” in the region. Whether you are a lifelong resident or a traveler passing through, Hartley’s offers a genuine taste of Cumberland comfort food, emphasizing fresh dough, savory sauces, and generous toppings that keep the community coming back for more.
Signature Fresh Dough: Local enthusiasts and visitors alike praise the quality of the dough and sauce, which are prepared fresh to ensure a superior crust.
The “Champ” Pizza: A massive 16-inch square-cut pizza featuring 16 slices, perfect for feeding large groups or families.
Famous Wedgies: A unique local favorite consisting of a hearty sandwich served on a specialized pizza shell, available in various protein options.
Meaty Buffalo Wings: Renowned for being cooked to perfection and served with a wide range of sauces, from mild to extra hot.
Speedy Service: Customers frequently highlight the efficiency of the staff, with many orders ready for pickup or delivery in under 20 minutes.
Hometown Hospitality: The staff is known for being friendly and helpful, contributing to the welcoming, community-focused vibe of the shop.
Menu and Offerings
Pizza
Available in Original or Fresh Dough. Sizes include 10″ (Small), 12″ (Medium), 14″ (Large), and 16″ (The Champ).
Item Name
Available Toppings
Plain Pizza
Pepperoni
1-Item Pizza
Mushrooms
2-Item Pizza
Sausage
3-Item Pizza
Onions
4-Item Pizza
Hot Peppers
5-Item Pizza
Green Peppers
6-Item Pizza
Bacon
7 Items or More
Hamburger
Sweet Peppers
Black Olives
Ham
Pineapple
Famous Wedgies
A signature sandwich served on a pizza shell. Available in Small (9″), Medium (12″), and Large (14″). Includes Provolone or American Cheese, Onions, Lettuce, Tomatoes, and Mayonnaise.
Item Name
Description
Ham & Cheese Wedgie
Thin sliced ham and melted cheese
Steak & Cheese Wedgie
Savory steak with choice of cheese
Italian Wedgie
Classic Italian meats and seasonings
Pepperoni Wedgie
Loaded with sliced pepperoni
Turkey & Cheese Wedgie
Lean turkey breast and cheese
Veggie Wedgie
Fresh assorted vegetables and cheese
Buffalo Wings
Includes Celery, Carrots, and Blue Cheese.
Sauce Options
Quantity Tiers
Hot / Medium / Mild
5 Pieces
Extra Hot / Butter Garlic
10 Pieces
Old Bay Butter / Sweet & Hot
20 Pieces
Old Bay Dry / Bar-B-Que
30 Pieces
Ranch Dry
40, 50, or 100 Pieces
Hoagies and Subs
Available in 9″ servings.
Item Name
Item Name
Italian Baked
Ham & Cheese
Steak & Cheese
Buffalo Chicken
Pepperoni Roll
Chicken Parm
Cold Italian
Chicken Tender
Turkey & Cheese
Extra Ingredients / Extra Meat
Chicken Dinners
Dinners include a Roll and choice of two sides (Jo Jos, French Fries, Macaroni Salad, or Cole Slaw).
