Saylor’s Front Street Pizzeria is a beloved, family-owned staple located right in the heart of downtown Dowagiac, Michigan. Serving up a highly praised signature crust that hits the perfect sweet spot between a classic hand-tossed and a traditional New York-style slice, this local gem has built a reputation for comforting flavors and speedy service. Housed in a charmingly historic building, it offers a warm, welcoming community vibe where locals and visitors alike gather for generous portions of pizza, hearty pasta dinners, and classic sub sandwiches.
Table service, Seating, High chairs, Good for kids, Dogs allowed inside, Dogs allowed outside
Parking
Free parking lot, Free street parking, Usually plenty of parking
Payment Methods
Credit cards, Debit cards, NFC mobile payments, Checks
Why Visit? Key Highlights
The Famed Chicken Bacon Ranch: Repeatedly celebrated by customers as the absolute best version of the flavor profile around town, keeping visitors consistently hooked.
Unique Fusion Crust: Diners love the distinct dough style, described as a delicious, satisfying hybrid of classic hand-tossed and thin New York-style.
Warm Community Spirit: Known for its exceptional hospitality, where the owners and staff treat everyone like family with friendly, quick, and accommodating service.
Great Pizza Sauce & Cheese Pull: Reviewers frequently highlight the high-quality, flavorful pizza sauce and excellent cheese consistency that elevates every pie.
Beyond Pizza Options: Excellent alternative favorites include the widely praised Roger Sub, savory baked spaghetti, and sweet cinnamon sticks.
Menu and Product Catalog
Specialty Pizzas
Item Name
Item Name
Supreme
Meatsa
Chic-n-Ranch
Meatball Pizza
Taco
Veggie Delight
Hawaiian
Pizza Bowl (Crustless Pizza)
Standard Pizzas
Item Name
Description
Cheese Pizza
Classic cheese base available in Small, Medium, Large, and 16″ sizes
One Topping Pizza
Customizable single-topping pie across all sizes
Two Topping Pizza
Choose any two toppings across all sizes
Three Topping Pizza
Load up with any three toppings across all sizes
Saylor Supreme Pizza
Signature specialty loaded pie across all sizes
Pasta
Item Name
Description
Spaghetti w/ Meat Sauce
Classic spaghetti topped with rich meat sauce, includes garlic bread
Lasagna
Layered pasta baked with cheese and sauce, includes garlic bread
Baked Spaghetti
Oven-baked pasta with melted cheese toppings, includes garlic bread
Mostaccioli
Hearty tube-shaped pasta baked to perfection, includes garlic bread
Meatballs
Savory protein add-on option for pasta dishes
Dinners
Item Name
Description
Shrimp
Fried shrimp basket served with French fries and a roll
Fish (Cod)
Tender cod fillets served with French fries and a roll
Rib Tips
Substantial portion of rib tips served with French fries and a roll
Mini Tips
A smaller portion of rib tips served with French fries and a roll
Chicken Strips
Crispy chicken strips served with French fries and a roll
Catfish Dinner
Southern-style fried catfish served with French fries and a roll
Hot Wing Dinner
Spicy, tossed wings served with French fries and a roll
Wing Ding Dinner
Crispy wing dings served with French fries and a roll
Sandwiches and Subs
Item Name
Item Name
Hamburger
Cheeseburger
Double Cheeseburger
RT Burger (Green Olive Burger)
Sausage Roll
Italian Sub
Meatball Sub
Ham & Cheese Sub
Roast Beef Sub
Pork Tenderloin Sandwich
Chicken Sandwich
Veggie Sub
Pizza Sub
French Dip Or Italian Beef
Turkey Sub
Veggie Turkey Sub
Roger Sub
Side Orders and Salads
Item Name
Description
Cinnamon Sticks
Sweet, baked dessert dough sticks available in Small, Medium, and Large
Jeffy Stix
Savory, cheesy garlic pull-apart sticks available in Small, Medium, and Large
Bread Sticks
Soft, freshly baked dough sticks; also available with cheese
Garlic Bread
Toasted bread seasoned with garlic; also available with cheese
Breaded Mushrooms
Crispy, golden-fried whole mushrooms
Mozzarella Cheese Sticks
Melted mozzarella coated in a crunchy seasoned breading
Pizza Bread
Toasted open-face bread topped with classic pizza ingredients
Chicken Nuggets
Available in crispy 6-piece, 9-piece, and 20-piece shareable sizes
Jalapeno Poppers
Spicy pepper bites stuffed with smooth cheese and fried
Chef Salad
Loaded fresh greens topped with meats, cheese, and vegetables
Chicken Salad
Crisp salad base crowned with tender chicken pieces
