If you are craving an authentic slice of the Big Apple right in the heart of Florida, Mr. Sammy’s Pizza is the ultimate destination. Located in the vibrant neighborhood of Lake Placid, this neighborhood gem brings genuine New York-style thin-crust pizza, rich Italian culinary traditions, and an unmatched sense of hospitality to the community. Stepping into Mr. Sammy’s feels less like visiting a restaurant and more like joining a lively family gathering. Boasting a cozy, trendy, and high-energy atmosphere, it is a local favorite where sports fans, neighborhood families, and visitors gather to enjoy exceptional food and quick, friendly service.
Casual, Cozy, Trendy atmosphere; Good for watching sports; Great beer and wine selection
Family & Pet Features
Extremely family-friendly, Kids’ menu available, High chairs provided, Dogs allowed outside
Parking Options
Free parking lot, Free street parking with plenty of spaces available
Payment Options
Credit cards, Debit cards
Why Visit? Key Highlights
Authentic New York Style: Famous for its authentic thin-crust pizza featuring a perfectly crunchy crust, balanced sauce, and premium cheese.
Family First Hospitality: The owner and staff treat every guest like family, often inviting children behind the counter to create their own custom pizzas for an unforgettable memory.
High-Quality Ingredients: From bread imported directly from Cassone Bakery in Portchester, NY to house-made sauces, quality shines through in every bite.
Cozy Community Spirit: A warm, welcoming hub that perfectly handles large groups, visiting sports fans, and local regulars with unparalleled fast service.
Menu and Offerings
Appetizers and Sides
Item Name
Description
Onion Petals
Available as a side or a larger appetizer portion
Hot Knots
Soft dough knots baked to perfection
Mozzarella Sticks
Golden fried cheese sticks, available in 6 or 12 pieces
French Fries
Classic golden fries, available as a side or appetizer
Garlic Parm French Fries
Tossed in rich garlic parmesan seasoning
Garlic Bread
Toasted with garlic butter, option to add cheese
Meatball
Flavorful Italian meatballs served individually or as a pair
Deep Fried Mushrooms
Crispy coated mushrooms served with dipping sauce
Salads
Item Name
Description
Side Salad
Crisp fresh greens and fresh seasonal garnishes
Antipasto Salad
Fresh romaine, tomatoes, cucumbers, black olives, marinated vegetables, Italian ham, salami, and cheese, served with garlic knots
House Salad
Fresh romaine, tomatoes, cucumbers, black olives, green peppers, and onions, served with garlic knots and choice of dressing
Wings
Item Name
Description
Traditional Wings
Available in quantities of 6 or 12. Flavors include BBQ, Garlic Parm, Buffalo Hot, Buffalo Mild, Butt Naked, and Hot Oil
Brick Oven Pizza
Item Name
Description
Mr. Sammy’s 1 Free Topping
Original, hand-tossed brick oven New York style pizza with your choice of one classic topping
Spicy Hot Afterburner
A delightful, zesty zip that is deeply enjoyable and beautifully balanced without being overpowering
Pepperoni Classic
A mouth-watering combination of pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, and green peppers
Meat Classic
A must for hearty appetites featuring pepperoni, Italian sausage, bacon, meatball, and salami
Mr. Sammy’s Classic
A true taste of Italy loaded with pepperoni, Italian sausage, green peppers, onions, mushrooms, meatballs, and black olives
Hawaiian Classic
The traditional tropical taste of mouth-watering chunks of sweet pineapple and savory ham
White Pizza
The original taste of three cheeses: ricotta, mozzarella, and parmesan over a fragrant garlic butter sauce
Veggie Classic
Garden-fresh delight featuring green peppers, mushrooms, onions, black olives, and fresh spinach with garlic butter sauce
Spinach Classic
A zesty combination of fresh sautéed spinach and mushrooms paired with sliced garden tomatoes
Lasagna Pie
A customer favorite featuring rich ricotta and a hearty spread of meat, topped with parmesan and mozzarella
Mr. Sammy’s Clam Classic
Plentiful clams slowly cooked in a rich garlic butter sauce and topped with melted mozzarella
Gluten-Free Cauliflower Crust
A crispy 10-inch cauliflower crust base customizable with your favorite cheese or specialty toppings
Strombolis and Calzones
Item Name
Description
Mr. Sammy’s Classic Stromboli
An old-time traditional blend of pepperoni, Italian sausage, green peppers, onions, mushrooms, and mozzarella, served with marinara
Cheesesteak Stromboli
Packed with savory shaved steak, melted cheese, onions, and green peppers
Stromboli Your Way
Create your own custom-baked turnover with three of your favorite toppings
Calzones
A delicious baked blend of mozzarella, ricotta, and parmesan cheeses inside a golden crust, served with marinara
Hot and Cold Subs
Item Name
Description
Philly Cheese Steak
Original Philadelphia golden steak sautéed with onions and green peppers, topped with provolone or mozzarella
Mr. Meatball Parm
Mega meatballs cooked to perfection, covered in homemade marinara and melted mozzarella
Italian Sausage
Mild Italian sausage with fresh peppers and onions, topped with mozzarella and marinara
Steak Onion Mushroom
Lots of sirloin steak smothered in fresh mushrooms and onions, finished with provolone cheese
Veal Parm Sub
Hand-cut and pounded to order, dipped in egg batter, breaded, fried golden, and topped with marinara and mozzarella
Chicken Parm Sub
Wide, juicy chicken cutlet completely covered in rich marinara and melted mozzarella
Chicken Philly
Tender chicken cutlet sautéed with green peppers and onions, finished with melted mozzarella
“Mr. Italy” (The Italian)
A cold sub loaded with premium ham, Genoa salami, fresh capicola, romaine, tomatoes, onions, provolone, and red peppers
The Big Ham
A hearty delight packed with high-quality mountain ham, wedge tomatoes, onions, and melted provolone
“Yo Salami”
Fresh Italian Genoa salami sliced thin and layered with romaine, onions, tomatoes, and provolone
Entrees
Item Name
Description
Lobster and Shrimp Ravioli
A delicious ravioli stuffed with real lobster and shrimp, smothered in a creamy, cheesy alfredo sauce
Spaghetti Marinara
A massive portion of thin Italian pasta slowly cooked to perfection and covered in homemade marinara sauce
Spaghetti with Clam Sauce
A delicious blend of clams sautéed in garlic oil and white wine, served over a large portion of pasta
Super Stuffed Shells
Three hearty jumbo pasta shells filled with a breathtaking blend of ricotta, mozzarella, and a secret spice blend, baked to perfection
Fettuccine Alfredo with Chicken
Classic fettuccine noodles cooked to order and tossed in a special, velvety dream-style cream sauce with chicken
Baked Ziti
A true Italian import cooked to exact tenderness with a perfect combination of ricotta, mozzarella, and secret spices
Meat Lasagna
The restaurant’s iconic, towering meat lasagna packed with rich layers of pasta, cheese, and savory meat sauce
5 Cheese Ravioli
A perfect blend of five premium cheeses stuffed inside pasta pillows and topped with Nana’s marinara
Meat Ravioli
Plump pasta pockets stuffed with seasoned beef and chopped meatballs, served in rich marinara
Chicken Parm Entree
A premium 6-ounce tender chicken cutlet, hand-trimmed and baked in savory marinara and thick mozzarella
Veal Parm Entree
Selected veal cut by hand, lightly battened, fried, and tossed in a house-made marinara topped with melted mozzarella
Eggplant Rollatini
Thinly sliced fresh eggplant dusted in flour and spices, stuffed with a rich blend of ricotta and mozzarella, and smothered in marinara
Eggplant Parm Entree
Thinly sliced eggplant dusted in flour, lightly deep-fried, layered with marinara, and baked with mozzarella
Garlic Parm Crusted Chicken
A hearty 6-ounce chicken cutlet hand-dipped in garlic butter and a specialty herb blend, lightly breaded and served with red peppers
Beverages and Desserts
Item Name
Description
Fountain Drinks
24 oz and 32 oz options including Coca-Cola, Coke Zero, Sprite, Root Beer, Lemonade, and Orange
Gold Peak Tea
Available in Sweet, Unsweet, and Raspberry flavors
Bottled Beers
Coors Light, Michelob Ultra, Bud Light, Corona, and Budweiser
On Tap Drafts
Served in a signature 16 oz frozen mug, featuring Michelob, Bud Light, Stella, and Amberbock
Non-Alcoholic Beers
Corona Extra NA and Michelob Ultra NA
Specialty Wines
A curated selection of red and white wines available by the glass
Authentic Tiramisu
Decadent, house-made espresso-layered classic Italian dessert
New York Cheesecake
Rich, dense, and authentic cream cheese cake
Cannolis
Delicious crispy pastry tubes filled with a sweet, creamy chocolate chip ricotta filling
